I Don’t Know Which Is Love Vol. 2 picks up right where the debut volume left off—smack dab in the middle of Mei Soraike’s chaotic, multi-suitor college life. Mei entered university determined to find a girlfriend, and somehow ended up as the unwitting crush of five very different women. This second volume dives deeper into those tangled relationships, showing how difficult it is to follow your heart when it’s being pulled in five wildly different directions. The comedy ramps up, the romantic tension rises, and poor Mei just tries to keep her head above water.
One of the standout sequences in this volume is a double-booked sleepover where Mei finds herself literally in the middle of a tug-of-war—emotionally and physically—between two of her suitors. It’s awkward, hilarious, and so on-brand for this manga’s tone. These moments showcase not only how overwhelmed Mei is by the affections coming her way, but also how much the story leans into its rom-com foundation. While there are hints of deeper feelings from the characters, the focus stays mostly on comedic situations that escalate into delightful chaos.
Each of Mei’s admirers gets a bit more fleshed out this time around. Whether it’s the energetic athlete, the sultry seductress, the soft-spoken sweetheart, or the mysterious upperclasswoman, they all bring something unique to the group dynamic. There’s real entertainment in seeing their personalities bounce off each other—especially when jealousy starts to bubble just beneath the surface. It’s like a romantic rollercoaster with Mei sitting in the front seat, trying desperately not to scream.
That said, while the setups are fun and engaging, the emotional depth of the series still feels somewhat surface-level. Mei’s character development, in particular, feels stalled. Her proactive energy from Volume 1 is softened here, and she often ends up being a passive observer of her own love life. It would be nice to see her assert herself more and start sorting through her feelings with intention, rather than just reacting to the whirlwind of affection around her.
Still, this volume shines with its comedic rhythm and playful tone. The writing is sharp and the humor often lands exactly where it should. For readers who enjoy lighthearted yuri with an ensemble cast and a heavy dose of romantic mishaps, this is a winning combination. There’s a self-awareness to the absurdity, and it leans into that with just the right amount of charm.
The artwork continues to be a major strength. The expressive faces, stylish character designs, and energetic paneling keep things visually engaging. Every flustered blush, exaggerated shock, or comedic beat is delivered with precision. It’s clear the artist is having fun with the scenarios, and that enthusiasm translates onto every page.
There’s also an interesting momentum building behind the scenes. While the current narrative leans into comedy, you can feel the potential for the story to take a more emotional turn. The characters are all so vibrant that it would be a missed opportunity not to dig a little deeper into their feelings—and Mei’s—as the series progresses.
I absolutely loved this volume and can’t wait to see how the series continues. I Don’t Know Which Is Love Vol. 2 keeps the energy high, the romance chaotic, and the laughs frequent. It’s a messy, lovable story of self-discovery, attraction, and romantic confusion—and I’m here for every single blush, pout, and flustered confession. Let the love polygon continue!
